How to tell if fish is fresh and from the auction? 5 clues to help you tell the difference
Buying fish through a screen can raise doubts, especially when we can’t see the fish in person. If we take the leap of faith of buying online, how can we know the product that arrives is of the highest quality?
Here is the definitive guide to identifying auction fish:
The smell of the sea (smell): Fresh fish doesn’t smell “fishy” in the negative sense many know. It should smell of salt water. If you detect an ammonia-like or overly strong smell, the fish has begun to deteriorate.
The fish’s gaze (sight): The eyes are the mirror of freshness. They should be bulging (outwards), bright, with an intense, transparent black pupil. If you see sunken, cloudy or whitish eyes, the fish is several days old.

The colour of the gills: Carefully lift the operculum (the gill cover). The gills should be bright red or deep pink, moist and clean, without strange mucus.

The touch test: The flesh of fresh fish is firm and elastic. If you press lightly with your finger and the mark disappears quickly, it is a sign of freshness. If the flesh stays “dented”, the fibres are already breaking down. Also bear in mind the type of fish: a fresh sole should have a slimy texture.

The look of the skin, scales and flesh: The skin should be shiny, almost metallic, and the scales firmly attached to the body. A fish that loses its scales easily has usually been handled too much or is not from the day. And in the case of hake, the flesh will not be white like the hake you find everywhere, but a pinkish shade, proof that its blood has not yet coagulated with the passing of days (or weeks).

How can you tell if a fishmonger works with auction fish?
Many fishmongers advertise auction fish but don’t say which auction. If we see them selling Delta mussels in the middle of winter or sardines during the closed season, we can be sure that fish is not local. We, as a village fishmonger, and unlike the big supermarkets, buy 95% of our fish at the L’Ametlla auction. For the simple reason that it is right next door, and because we know that customers who like good fish know how to tell the difference.
More articles

Which fish is in season? The calendar of auction fish in the Mediterranean
Fish has its seasons too. We guide you season by season through the fish and shellfish from the Mediterranean auction: when anchovies, sardines, dolph…

The fish that empties other people’s seas: Senegal’s fishing crisis
Overfishing by foreign fleets has emptied Senegal’s fishing grounds: fishermen with no fish, families with no protein and forced migration towards the…

Fish for kids, fish without bones
Introducing fish into children’s diets is one of the best investments in your kids’ health. The benefits of eating fresh fish are key: Omega-3 is esse…